31.738
Bearbeitungen
Restorative Justice: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen
Restorative Justice (Quelltext anzeigen)
Version vom 17. Juni 2009, 16:59 Uhr
, 16:59, 17. Jun. 2009keine Bearbeitungszusammenfassung
Tiao (Diskussion | Beiträge) |
Tiao (Diskussion | Beiträge) |
||
| Zeile 101: | Zeile 101: | ||
Several interesting attempts can be found in the book | Several interesting attempts can be found in the book “The editors are Andrew von Hirsch, Julian Roberts, Anthony E. Bottoms, Kent Roach and Mara Schiff (Hart 2003). Two of the chapters can be seen as attempts to combine “the best” from penal law and restorative justice. In my view, we get the worst from both from the merged product. | ||
First an article by Anthony Duff. He simply demands retribution as an integral part of restoration. Restoration, he claims, “is not only compatible with retribution, it requires retribution” (p.43, the italics are his). And then, at (p.55): “What they deserve to suffer is not just ‘pain or a burden’, but the particular kind of painful burden which is integral to the recognition of guilt: they deserve to suffer that because it is an appropriate response to their wrongdoing; and criminal mediation aims precisely to impose or induce that kind of suffering”. | First an article by Anthony Duff. He simply demands retribution as an integral part of restoration. Restoration, he claims, “is not only compatible with retribution, it requires retribution” (p.43, the italics are his). And then, at (p.55): “What they deserve to suffer is not just ‘pain or a burden’, but the particular kind of painful burden which is integral to the recognition of guilt: they deserve to suffer that because it is an appropriate response to their wrongdoing; and criminal mediation aims precisely to impose or induce that kind of suffering”. | ||
| Zeile 153: | Zeile 153: | ||
*Braithwaite, John (2002) Setting Standards for Restorative Justice. British Journal of Criminology 42: 563-577. | *Braithwaite, John (2002) Setting Standards for Restorative Justice. British Journal of Criminology 42: 563-577. | ||
*v. Hirsch, Andrew, Julian Roberts, Anthony E. Bottoms, Kent Roach und Maria Schiff (2003) | *v. Hirsch, Andrew, Julian Roberts, Anthony E. Bottoms, Kent Roach und Maria Schiff (2003) Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice - Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms?” Hart. | ||
*Zehr, Howard (1990) Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice. Waterloo, ONTARIO: Herald Press. | *Zehr, Howard (1990) Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice. Waterloo, ONTARIO: Herald Press. | ||