Kriminelle Karriere: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen

5.420 Bytes hinzugefügt ,  09:40, 31. Mär. 2011
keine Bearbeitungszusammenfassung
Zeile 1: Zeile 1:
== Achtung Baustelle- betreten auf eigene gefahr == 21.03.2011 ==  
== Achtung Baustelle- betreten auf eigene Gefahr == 31.03.2011 ==  




Zeile 21: Zeile 21:
Lyle Shannon (1988, 1991) verknüpfte Polizeiinformationen über die Angehörigen der Geburtsjahrgänge 1942, 1949 und 1955 mit vertiefenden Interviews derjenigen, die bis zu ihrem 18. Geburtstag in Racine, Wisconsin, geblieben waren. Sie fand heraus, dass rund 80% aller schwereren Straftaten (felonies) auf einen Anteil von ca. 5% jeder Kohorte zurückging - also einen Anteil von chronischen oder Karriere-Delinquenten.  
Lyle Shannon (1988, 1991) verknüpfte Polizeiinformationen über die Angehörigen der Geburtsjahrgänge 1942, 1949 und 1955 mit vertiefenden Interviews derjenigen, die bis zu ihrem 18. Geburtstag in Racine, Wisconsin, geblieben waren. Sie fand heraus, dass rund 80% aller schwereren Straftaten (felonies) auf einen Anteil von ca. 5% jeder Kohorte zurückging - also einen Anteil von chronischen oder Karriere-Delinquenten.  


In neuerer Zeit trat der Streit zwischen Blumstein und seinen Mitarbeitern (Barnett, Blumstein, and Farrington; Blumstein, Cohen, and Farrington, 1988a, 1988b) und Gottfredson und Hirschi (1988, 1990) über die Stabilität krimineller Karrieren in den Vordergrund. Sampson and Laubs sogenannte "age-graded theory of informal social control" räumt sowohl Stabilität als auch Veränderung genügend Platz ein. Die beiden Autoren postulieren, dass Veränderungen in den sozialen Bindungen zu Individuen und Institutionen (z.B. Familie, Bildungssystem, Arbeit) dazu beitragen, ein Individuum zu mehr oder weniger Deliquenz oder zum Ausstieg aus der Delinquenz zu bewegen. Während zum Beispiel die Eheschließung einen Wendepunkt hin zu stärkeren Bindungen an die konventionelle Gesellschaft (Laub, Nagin & Sampson) und weg von gleichaltrigen delinquenten Bezugspersonen darstellen kann, könnte das Ausbleiben solcher Ereignisse im Leben eines Menschen dazu führen, dass diese Person weiterhin delinquent agiert.
Sampson und Laub stellen drei wichtige theoretische Behauptungen auf: (1) the structural context of family and school social controls explains delinquency in childhood and adolescence; (2) this leads to a continuity in antisocial behavior from childhood through adulthood across many social domains; and (3) social bonds in adulthood to institutions such as family and employment explain changes in criminal behavior over the life-course, despite early criminal propensity. Sampson and Laub's developmental model acknowledges the potential for both stability and change in criminal behavior over time. While other psychologically oriented models of individual criminal behavior provide a more static view of criminality within the individual over time (e.g., Gottfredson and Hirschi, 1990), the age-graded theory of social control allows for the possibility of changes in behavior fluctuating with changing levels of attachment or social bonding over time. At the population level, decreasing levels of offending at later ages are attributed to the termination in offending behavior of some, coupled with the persistence in offending behavior of others. While Sampson and Laub note that "there is considerable evidence that antisocial behavior is relatively stable across stages of the life-course," there also are many opportunities for the links in the "chain of adversity" to be broken over time (pp. 11, 15).
The most prominent of the "static" or "continuity" theories of crime is Gottfredson and Hirschi's (1990) self-control theory of crime. Gottfredson and Hirschi (1988, 1990) assert that both crime and criminality are stable across the life-course and that a singular underlying individual characteristic, self-control, is predictive of offending behavior. Self-control is established early in life (before the age of eight) and is related to parental child-rearing techniques. Those parents who are able to consistently and fairly discipline children and teach them to resist impulsive behavior will instill in their children a high level of self-control. Across the lifespan, an individual's level of self-control will remain stable but can manifest itself in many different ways. Childhood antisocial behavior, adolescent and adult criminality, problem drinking, excessive speeding, or any other impulsive or deviant activity could be traced back to low levels of self-control. Gottfredson and Hirschi (1990) attribute decreasing levels of offending at later ages in the age-crime curve to a gradual "aging-out" of all offenders, reflective of relative stability over time, as opposed to the termination of offending by some. Support for the existence of an underlying latent trait predictive of continuity in offending has been found by those such as Greenberg and Rowe, Osgood, and Nicewander.
Debates between those advocating a more dynamic versus a static view of offending behavior have spawned a related question on the relationship of past to future offending: Does prior offending have a subsequent causal impact on future offending or do time-stable individual differences cause persistence in offending over time? This question, framed in terms of the existence of either state dependence or persistent heterogeneity, has been advanced by Nagin and his colleagues (Nagin and Farrington, 1992a, 1992b; Nagin and Paternoster, 1991). State dependence implies that the commission of a crime may raise the probability that an individual will commit a subsequent crime. According to state dependence, prior participation in offending has an "actual behavioral effect" (Nagin and Paternoster, p. 163) on subsequent offending (a dynamic approach). On the other hand, population heterogeneity implies that past and future offending are related only inasmuch as they are both related to an unmeasured criminal propensity that is stable over time within the individual (a static approach). Mixed conclusions have been drawn from this vein of research—support has been found for both the hypotheses of state-dependence (Nagin and Farrington, 1992a; Nagin and Paternoster) and population heterogeneity (Loeber and Snyder; Nagin and Farrington, 1992a, 1992b).
Read more: Criminal Careers - Contemporary Issues And Controversies - Offending, Individual, Time, Nagin, Control, and Farrington http://law.jrank.org/pages/830/Criminal-Careers-Contemporary-issues-controversies.html#ixzz1I9y0KUsy


== Karrieremodelle ==
== Karrieremodelle ==
31.738

Bearbeitungen