31.738
Bearbeitungen
Abolitionism: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen
→Open Questions
Tiao (Diskussion | Beiträge) |
Tiao (Diskussion | Beiträge) |
||
| Zeile 176: | Zeile 176: | ||
=== Open Questions=== | === Open Questions=== | ||
Questions: negative reforms only (Mathiesen, Frankfurter Schule, ...) oder positive Vorschläge (Thomas Bianchi). | *What is to be abolished? | ||
Problem der moralischen Basis des Abolitionsdiskurses: keine unschuldigen Opfer wie die Sklaven, sondern schuldige Täter. | *Prison as punishment, i.e. as a punitive reaction to crime, i.e. as a legal reaction to a violation of criminal law that consists of the intentional infliction of suffering to make someone "pay" for his crime. | ||
*Not: confinement per se. Not confinement for medical reasons or reasons of public security (serial killer). | |||
*Empirical hypothesis: public security can be guaranteed as well as with prisons or even better by ambulatory measures. | |||
+Questions: negative reforms only (Mathiesen, Frankfurter Schule, ...) oder positive Vorschläge (Thomas Bianchi). | |||
*Problem der moralischen Basis des Abolitionsdiskurses: keine unschuldigen Opfer wie die Sklaven, sondern schuldige Täter. | |||
==Criminal Law and the Criminal Justice System== | ==Criminal Law and the Criminal Justice System== | ||